$99 Minimum · Free Shipping at $129*1–3 Day Nationwide DeliveryArrives Cold or We Make It RightBack in stock Catfish Fillets, 5–7 oz →

Wrong, missing or substituted items

Updated Oct 28, 2026

Missing items: check the whole box first — items are sometimes packed under the liner or ice packs. If something is still missing, email [email protected] with your order number and the missing items, and we’ll reship or refund them.

Wrong items or flavors: email us with your order number and a photo of what you received. There’s no need to send anything back — the items are perishable, so please keep them. We’ll send the correct items or refund them.

Substitutions: we never substitute an item without asking. If something in your order runs out before it ships, we’ll email you first with options — a similar item or a refund for that item.

Was this helpful?

Do you need more help?

We reply within 24 hours on business days. Weekend messages are answered the next business day.

Protected by reCAPTCHA.
Delivered Cold helperAfter hours · we reply by 9 am next business day